Deleted Comment to “Go Make Me a Sandwich” Blog

So I decided to pay the “Go Make Me a Sandwich” blog on feminism in gaming a visit and left the following comment on a recent post about the Dungeons and Dragons manuals. The blog owner removed my comment—not by actually erasing it from view as you can see, but by excising my text and then pasting a silly meme in its place. Since it is a privately owned blog, I suppose this is within her right, even  if I feel it is discouraging dialogue by censoring dissent. But for those of you visiting her blog and curious what my post said, let me provide it for you:

With regards to the entire trend of so-called “sexualization” of female characters in art, there is a simple explanation for that. Straight male artists, myself included, like drawing pictures of hot women. Always have, always will. This predates patriarchy as a social institution by thousands upon thousands of years. And it’s not an impulse exclusive to straight males either, as a casual glance at the romance section in most bookstores will show you. Nothing more to it than good ol’ emotions inspiring art.

And it’s not necessarily sexism either. There is a world of difference between sexual desire inspiring art and restricting one sex’s opportunities or denying their humanity. Even so-called “objectification” is more about LIMITING one sex to a certain role (namely tool of reproduction) than simply appreciating their sex appeal. The female characters you’re complaining about may have been designed with sex appeal in mind (although in many cultures around the world, showing more skin is a daily fact of life), but they’re hardly barefoot-and-pregnant types with no agency.

On the other hand, you do raise a valid point about double standards in how men and women in this kind of art are represented, but I would chalk that up to male artists predominating this genre. Part of that might have more to do with more men than women being interested in art of this genre, but I wouldn’t rule out gender discrimination in hiring artists either.

2 thoughts on “Deleted Comment to “Go Make Me a Sandwich” Blog

  1. Y’know, once upon a time, i actually liked her blog, but now it’s just like “you’ll just never please some people”. It reminds me of the remark that Liana Kerzner made to the effect that people may be inclined to not include ANY female representation in their games simply for fear that any good faith attempts they make will be torn down and destroyed by people you’ll never make happy anyway.

    The last point you made in your comment might not be as true as you suppose. I think that people would’ve been outraged that Margaret Brundage was posthumously honored at the Hugos this year if they actually had any idea who she was.

    1. Of course, there are plenty of female artists like Brundage who produce “sexualized” depictions of women too. Those are the ones who get charged with “internalized misogyny”. But if I had to guess, at least a slightly larger proportion of artists working with such subject matter would be heterosexual men, for obvious reasons.

      Otherwise I think you raise good points.

What did you think?

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s